Use code MHF20 for 20% off orders of $150+ • Free FedEx ground shipping on orders of $150+ • Click here for details
Oil & Vinegar

Extra Virgin Olive Oil

We have a lot of favorite foods, but Extra Virgin Olive Oil is sort of our thing. We carry only the finest extra virgin olive oils from producers we know personally. This means scouring the globe for the best tasting oil, every year; working directly with producers and visiting their estates; and meticulously tasting and evaluating to bring you the best range of olive oils to suit any palate or purpose. In addition, all of our California olive oils are Certified Extra Virgin by the California Olive Oil Council. Learn more about How to Buy Real Extra Virgin Olive Oil. Need some help deciding? Call us at (888) 952-4005.

29 products
Bottle of Seka Hill Arbequina extra virgin olive oil
Arbequina Extra Virgin Olive Oil from Séka Hills
$25.95
Tin of Fat Gold California Extra Virgin Olive Oil
Extra Virgin Olive Oil from Fat Gold
$38.95 Sold out
Bottle of Frantoio Grove Extra Virgin Olive Oil
Organic Extra Virgin Olive Oil from Frantoio Grove
$25.95
Olive Truck Tuscan Blend
Tuscan Blend Extra Virgin Olive Oil from Olive Truck
$33.95
2023 500ml tin of Olivaia OLA Block X Super Blend extra virgin olive oil
Block X Super Blend Extra Virgin Olive Oil from Olivaia's OLA
$33.95
Bottle of Katz Chef Pick extra virgin olive oil
Chef's Pick Organic Extra Virgin Olive Oil from Katz
$29.95
Bottle of Zuccardi Organic Blend extra virgin olive oil
Organic Blend Extra Virgin Olive Oil from Familia Zuccardi
$25.95
Bottle of Zuccardi Arauco Extra Virgin Olive Oil
Arauco Extra Virgin Olive Oil from Familia Zuccardi
$27.95
Black square-shaped bottle of Olio Verde Extra Virgin Olive Oil
Extra Virgin Olive Oil from Olio Verde
$37.95
250ml bottle of Frescobaldi Laudemio extra virgin olive oil
Laudemio Extra Virgin Olive Oil from Frescobaldi
From: $28.95
Crudo Extra Virgin Olive Oil
Extra Virgin Olive Oil from Crudo
$28.95
ColleMassari organic extra virgin olive oil
I.G.P. Organic Extra Virgin Olive Oil from Castello ColleMassari
$34.95
500ml tin of Merula Extra Virgin Olive Oil
Merula Extra Virgin Olive Oil from Marqués de Valdueza
$26.95
Vieiru DOP Extra Virgin Olive Oil
Vieiru DOP Extra Virgin Olive Oil
$28.95
Intosso Extra Virgin Olive Oil by Rustichella d'Abruzzo - Bottle
Intosso Extra Virgin Olive Oil from Rustichella d'Abruzzo
$34.95
Tuscan Olive Oil & Vinegar Set
Tuscan Olive Oil & Vinegar Set
From: $39.00
Olive Oil & Vinegar Gift Collection from Calivirgin
Olive Oil & Vinegar Gift Collection from Calivirgin
$38.95
Gold box holding three small bottles of Boccabella extra virgin olive oil
Extra Virgin Olive Oil Gift Box from Boccabella Farms
$38.95
Winemaker's Blend Extra Virgin Olive Oil from Boccabella Farms
Winemaker's Blend Extra Virgin Olive Oil from Boccabella Farms
$37.95 Sold out
2024 Seka Hills Olio Nuovo
Olio Nuovo from Séka Hills
$28.95
Bondolio 2023 organic extra virgin olive oil
Bondolio California Extra Virgin Olive Oil
$36.95
Seka Hills Taggiasca extra virgin olive oil
Taggiasca Extra Virgin Olive Oil from Séka Hills
$17.95
Box of Seka Hills 3 liter arbequina extra virgin olive oil
3-Liter Box Extra Virgin Olive Oil from Séka Hills
$84.95 Sold out
Bottle of 2022 harvest Santidu, Sardinian extra virgin olive oil
Extra Virgin Olive Oil from Santidu
$30.95 Sold out
Tenuta di Capezzana Organic Extra Virgin Olive Oil
Organic Extra Virgin Olive Oil from Tenuta di Capezzana
$41.95 Sold out
Frantoi Cutrera Nocellara Extra Virgin Olive Oil
Nocellara Extra Virgin Olive Oil from Frantoi Cutrera
$34.95 Sold out
Spedalotto Tonda Iblea Organic Extra Virgin Olive Oil
Tonda Iblea Organic Extra Virgin Olive Oil D.O.P. from Spedalotto
$35.95 Sold out
Bottle of Titone DOP extra virgin olive oil
Organic DOP Extra Virgin Olive Oil from Titone
$45.00 Sold out
1 liter bottle of Sapori Divini Extra Virgin Olive Oil
Sapori Divini Extra Virgin Olive Oil
$34.95 Sold out